Falling Glass Injures Girl at Fresno State Football Game, Witnesses Say
Vacant for 50 Years, Bank of Italy Building Could Rise Again
Will Boswell-Vidovich Water War Ruin Kings County Farming?
Pazin Touts His Credentials, Calls Soria a Credit Grabber.
Pence Returns to Valley Monday to Campaign for Valadao
New Desalination Plant Will Boost California’s Drought-Depleted Water Supplies
SF Rat Infestation Provides a Lesson for Fresno Residents
LA Leader Resigns City Council Seat Over Racist Remarks
California Expands Largest US Illegal Pot Eradication Effort
LA Council Faces Uncertainty Amid Furor Over Racist Remarks
As Suicides Rise Dramatically, US Military Seeks Solutions
US, UK Hold Drone Drill in Persian Gulf After Iran Seizures
Watch: Stormchaser Reed Timmer’s Bonkers Video of Hurricane Ian
NASA Crashes Spacecraft Into Asteroid. Photos Show Last Moments of Successful Mission.
Court Deals Heavy Blow to Trump in Mar-a-Lago Records Probe
Who Is Leading the Crackdown on Iran’s Protests?
Musk Wants US to Pay Tab for His Satellite Network over Ukraine
How Iran’s Security Forces Carried Out ‘Bloody Friday’ Massacre
Ukraine Gets More Air Defense Pledges as Russia Hits Cities
UK’s New Prime Minister and King Face Huge Challenges: Ian Bremmer
Pazin Touts His Credentials, Calls Soria a Credit Grabber.
Pence Returns to Valley Monday to Campaign for Valadao
Why McCarthy’s Vow to Ax New IRS Auditors and Agents Could Backfire
Tight Poll Gives Maher Reason for Optimism, but Costa Confident of Victory
Want to Wager That Both of California’s Betting Measures Fail?
Vehicle Crash Cancels Classes at Madera Community College
State Grants of Nearly $5M Help Train More Healthcare Workers for Underserved Valley
Why $20 Million Matters? Foundation Shares Inspiring Scholarship Stories
Clovis Alum’s Estate Gives Largest Ever Gift to District’s Foundation
Wow! MacKenzie Scott Gifts $20M to Fresno Unified’s New Foundation
Farmers Face a Reckoning Over Water Rights as Drought Persists
Tulare County Has Waited Far Too Long for Clean, Safe Drinking Water
California Needs Clear Rules About Where Housing Can Be Built: Walters
Inept Transition to Green Energy Fuels California’s High Gas Prices
Prop. 30 Is So Bad It Might Be Good for California
Let the Debate Begin: Is Judge Baseball’s ‘Real’ Season HR King?
Former NFL Player, 2nd Rock Climber Found Dead in California
California Eyes Making Girls Flag Football a School Sport
Dodger Great Maury Wills, Who Revived the Art of the Stolen Base, Dies at 89
Judge Is Two Home Runs Shy of Setting Baseball’s ‘Real’ Season Record
UNFILTERED — Fall Elections and $7 Billion Transportation Tax
UNFILTERED – State of Fresno County Address, California Gas Prices, Women in Iran
UNFILTERED – Squaw Bill Signed, Dems’ Criticism of Smittcamp, Caglia Environmental and Armenia
UNFILTERED – DeSantis’ Treatment of Immigrants, Elections Update, Fresno County Redistricting
UNFILTERED – Keeping Them Honest In The Valley
While it’s not yet formal policy, those who manage California’s vast water system are edging toward a historic reallocation of the state’s shrinking supply that could have a life-altering impact on its largest-in-the-nation agricultural industry.
For many years, farmers have used about 80% of the water diverted from rivers for human use, with the rest going to urban areas for drinking, watering lawns, maintaining swimming pools, taking showers, cooking, and commercial or industrial use.
Prolonged drought has compelled all users to make do with less. However, the biggest loser has been the environment — free flows to maintain habitat for fish and other aquatic species — which generally gets about 50% of the total flow.
In recent years, federal judges have ordered cuts in agricultural water diversions to enforce the Endangered Species Act, and the state Water Resources Control Board has moved in the same direction on an emergency basis due to drought. However, environmental groups want permanent habitat-enhancing reductions.
Related Story: California Needs Clear Rules About Where Housing Can Be Built: Walters
Former Gov. Jerry Brown and his successor, Gavin Newsom, have sought “voluntary agreements” by which agricultural water agencies would curtail diversions to maintain river flows, but results have been scanty at best.
Without such agreements, the water board could implement mandatory reductions, but they would be viewed by farmers as an assault on their historic water rights and probably trigger massive legal battles.
The key principle in these conflicts is that water belongs to the public as a whole and must be put to “beneficial use,” as defined in a 1943 amendment to the state constitution, which declares that authorities must prevent “waste or unreasonable use or unreasonable method of use of water…”
Environmentalists believe the constitution thus authorizes the state water board to curtail agricultural diversions for the protection of habitat, but the 1943 amendment also declares, “In the enactment of this code the Legislature does not intend thereby to effect any change in the law relating to water rights.”
That obvious legal dichotomy is the crux of the situation.
Whether, indeed, the state water board is gearing up for a showdown over water rights, some of which stretch back to the 19th century, is the subject of much speculation in water circles.
Early this year, water board chairman Joaquin Esquivel told a gathering of water officials, “We know we have to change the system. Water rights can be there as a tool to be able to manage supplies through not just a drought but when there is water again. Our water rights system can be there to facilitate decisions on projects and help us make decisions, or they can be a hindrance.”
Related Story: Tulare County Has Waited Far Too Long for Clean, Safe Drinking Water
The Colorado River flows through the Grand Canyon on the Hualapai reservation, Monday, Aug. 15, 2022, in northwestern Arizona. The river’s reduced flow is causing water shortages in the seven U.S. states and Mexico. (AP File)
While the water rights issue percolates in Northern California, there’s a similar conflict underway in Southern California over how much water the state diverts from a severely threatened Colorado River.
California is legally entitled to 4.4 million acre-feet per year, with the vast majority of that going to the Imperial Irrigation District and other agricultural users, but the river’s flow has dropped dramatically.
The federal government demands that California and other states that draw from the river, principally Nevada and Arizona, reduce diversions by 2-to-4 million acre-feet per year, and threatens to mandate cuts under the “beneficial use” doctrine if they cannot agree.
California has offered a 400,000 acre-foot reduction, only 9%, but that’s not enough to satisfy the other states and the outcome is very much in doubt.
Farmers’ water rights are clearly not as sacrosanct as they once seemed to be, and as drought persists the stage is being set for a monumental reckoning of some kind.
Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He began his professional career in 1960, at age 16, at the Humboldt Times. For more columns by Walters, go to calmatters.org/commentary.
GV Wire encourages vigorous debate from people and organizations on local, state, and national issues. Submit your op-ed to rreed@gvwire.com for consideration.
RIP, Robbie Coltrane, 72. As Hagrid, He Delivered This Memorable Line to Harry Potter
Dan Walters has been a journalist for nearly 60 years, spending all but a few of those years working for California newspapers. He has written more than 9,000 columns about the state and its politics and is the founding editor of the “California Political Almanac.” Dan has also been a frequent guest on national television news shows, commenting on California issues and policies.